Welcome to the Sunday edition of The Mexpatriate. In today’s newsletter:
June 5 Elections: The Post-Game Show
Lithium, lithium everywhere and not an ounce to sell?
Please share your comments, feedback and questions, and feel free to forward this to anyone who may be interested. You will find all sources linked to directly in the body of the text.
June 5 Elections: The Post-Game Show
In Numbers
Aguascalientes:
Teresa Jiménez (PAN-PRI-PRD) 53.56%
Nora Ruvalcaba (MORENA) 33.68%
Durango:
Estéban Villegas (PAN-PRI-PRD) 55.1%
Marina Vitela (MORENA) 37.5%
Hidalgo:
Julio Menchaca (MORENA) 61.5%
Carolina Viggiano (PAN-PRI-PRD) 31.3%
Oaxaca:
Salomón Jara (MORENA) 60.1%
Alejandro Avilés (PRI-PRD) 25%
Quintana Roo:
Mara Lezama (MORENA) 56.4%
Laura Lynn Fernández (PAN-PRD) 16.13%
Tamaulipas:
Américo Villarreal (MORENA) 49.9%
César Verástegui (PAN-PRI-PRD) 44.2%
Mexico now has 9 female governors, the most in its history
Voter turnout was highest in Tamaulipas (53% of eligible voters) and lowest in Oaxaca (38% of eligible voters)
MORENA, the ruling party, now governs 58% of the population of Mexico at a state level. Before 2018, MORENA governed in zero states.
A few snippets from political pundits this week:
“It’s difficult to exaggerate the magnitude of the earthquake that has shaken our party system in just the last four or five years…”
—Carlos Bravo Regidor
“This is a worrying phenomenon, of ‘priismo’ mutating into ‘morenismo’…it is not a good omen for democratic life in the country. The opposition alliance [PAN-PRI-PRD], instead of ‘having a shot’ in 2024 will shoot itself in the foot if there is not a mea culpa for what the PAN and PRI have done in the past.”
—Denise Dresser
“We have attended many funerals for the PRI over the years…but they still poll at 17% of voter intention nationally.”
—Leo Zuckermann
“MORENA is a party of the masses, less institutionalized than the PRI. MORENA is more fluid, akin to a social movement, and that is a fundamental difference. It has also depended on a charismatic figure (AMLO).”
—Mario Arriagada
“This is tacit bi-partisanship. On the one side, PRIMOR (PRI-MORENA) and on the other PRIAN (PRI-PAN). Both have approximately the same voter support in polls, 45% and 40% respectively. Two different ways of seeing the country that have been in gestation since the 1980s. Let’s see if they formally consolidate now.”
—Pablo Majluf
“Yes, the PVEM (Partido Verde Ecologista de México) has had success—fentanyl has also had success—but I think there is not a more harmful party in Mexico.”
—Paula Sofía Vázquez
And in one of the most bizarre pieces of political theatre to grace the internet, here is Layda Sansores (MORENA governor of Campeche) holding a fake funeral service for her political rival, ex-governor of Campeche and besieged president of the PRI, Alejandro “Alito” Moreno:
Lithium, lithium everywhere and not an ounce to sell?
Lithium—element number 3 on the periodic table—has the lowest density of all metals. Present in the primordial soup along with hydrogen and helium soon after The Big Bang, lithium is in the stars above us, the igneous rocks and waters beneath us, and in the battery of the device you’re using to read these words.
Identified by a Swedish chemist in 1817, lithium has proven to have many uses, from industry to medicine to soft drinks—did you know lithium carbonate was the “up” part of the original “7 Up”?
Lithium-ion rechargeable battery technology was commercialized in the early 1990s, and its first application was in camcorders and digital cameras. Along with all the portable electronic devices we’ve come to depend on, the transition to hybrid and electric vehicles has increased the demand for lithium: by 2040, the International Energy Agency predicts it will have increased 42 times relative to 2020 levels. The price of lithium soared in 2021, prompting a rush to invest in new mining projects and sparking what could be the defining geopolitical resource race of our era.
Today most lithium is mined in Chile, Australia and China, but “white gold” became a hot topic in Mexico during debates on President López Obrador’s energy reform bill this year. In 2018, a lithium deposit discovered in the deserts of Sonora was reported by the British/Chinese mining company Bacanora to be one of the largest in the world. AMLO and MORENA, defeated in their grander constitutional reform attempt, rushed through reforms of the “Ley Minera” on April 20 to nationalize lithium extraction. “The lithium is ours,” the president declared triumphantly. Indeed. But will it be worth claiming?
Lithium reserves are classified into three categories: salt pans, hard rock deposits and clay deposits. Using today’s technology, mining these various sources is resource-intensive and costly. Chilean lithium is mostly found in salt pans in the Atacama desert (the most arid place on Earth) and Australia’s in hard rock deposits. Mexico does not appear on the lists of the world’s largest lithium reserves because while it may have abundant lithium resources, these are not considered reserves unless extractable.
“Starting with the assumption we have significant lithium reserves in Mexico is not accurate,” notes Sergio Almazán, president of the Engineer’s Association of Mines, Metallurgists and Geologists of Mexico. “The concern is that in Mexico we don’t have any production now, we have clay deposits, and there is much yet to study…to see if his lithium can be extracted.” In July 2021, Tesla filed a patent on a new method of lithium extraction from clay that is purported to be less environmentally damaging—it takes an estimated 500,000 gallons of water to extract one metric ton of lithium—although it is not clear yet how efficient it will be compared to other methods.
There are 36 lithium mining concessions in Mexico today, all financed by foreign companies. On June 6, AMLO confirmed that existing contracts will be respected if they are “in order”, but that no further concessions will be granted since his government will create a state-run company to extract lithium. Massive investment—in capital, expertise and time—is needed to begin mining lithium: Bacanora began exploratory studies in Sonora in 2010 and is only slated to begin operations in 2023. Bolivia embarked on a similar adventure in nationalized lithium mining that has thus far led nowhere: “they put the lithium in government hands, it’s been fifteen years and nothing has been produced…the company is in debt.”
Since mineral rights are already protected by Article 27 of the Mexican constitution, any extraction by private entities is regulated and taxed. In countries that successfully produce large quantities of lithium, the mines are privately owned and operated and governments have encouraged their investment, sometimes at the expense of local communities and environmental damage. “As renewable energy resources are abundant but diffuse, technologies for capturing, storing and transporting them will instead become more important,” noted a 2018 journal article in Energy Research and Social Science. “International energy competition may therefore shift from control over physical resources and their locations and transportation routes to technology and intellectual property rights.”
Celebrating that now all the lithium-laced clay belongs to “the people”, when its only economic value lies in a complex, expensive extraction process that the Mexican state cannot execute, could be short-sighted at best.
“The success of the reform will be measured in years to come and will have more to do with the interest of governments after AMLO…the political future of Mexico will determine the future of its lithium.”